Childrens' book philosophy 11: Mick Inkpen on the use/mention distinction
[This is from a story about a doll left behind when a family moves house; the "little thing" is the doll]
Suddenly the glare of a torch beam stung the little thing's eyes.
"What have we got here?" said a voice.
"Oh, it's nothing," said another. "Let the new people get rid of it."
"So that's my name," thought the little thing, "Nothing!"
Then, in the quiet, he heard the patter of feet and a mouse came running towards him.
"New People always try to get rid of you," it said, without introducing itself. It looked at him. "Seen you under the rug. What are you?"
"Nothing," replied Nothing.
"Well, nothing or not, you can't stay here, not with New People coming," said the mouse.
- from Mick Inkpen, "Nothing," in The Mick Inkpen Treasury
(Compare Odysseus' cunning trick against the Cyclops, described here.)
I don't think this is an
I don't think this is an example of the use-mention. 'Nothing' is just being used in two different ways—as a name and as an abstract noun.
It reminds me of this passage from Alice Through the Looking Glass:
"I see nobody on the road," said Alice.
"I only wish I had such eyes," the King remarked in a fretful tone. "To be able to see Nobody! And at that distance, too! Why, it's as much as I can do to see real people, by this light!"
In reply to I don't think this is an by Phil
I like the Alice quote,
I like the Alice quote, thanks! I guess whether my example counts as use/mention depends whether you think treating a word as a name is "mentioning" the word. Upon reflection maybe you're right that it isn't.
Add new comment
Blog Archive
- February 2025 (2)
- January 2025 (1)
- December 2024 (4)
- November 2024 (2)
- September 2024 (4)
- July 2024 (2)
- March 2024 (1)
- February 2024 (2)
- December 2023 (2)
- November 2023 (2)
- October 2023 (3)
- September 2023 (3)
- August 2023 (1)
- July 2023 (1)
- June 2023 (2)
- May 2023 (3)
- April 2023 (3)
- March 2023 (6)
- February 2023 (2)
- January 2023 (5)
- November 2022 (3)
- October 2022 (1)
- September 2022 (1)
- August 2022 (1)
- July 2022 (6)
- May 2022 (3)
- April 2022 (2)
- March 2022 (3)
- January 2022 (3)
- December 2021 (1)
- November 2021 (3)
- October 2021 (1)
- September 2021 (3)
- August 2021 (4)
- July 2021 (2)
- June 2021 (3)
Actually on further
Actually on further reflection I don't think this exemplifies the use/mention distinction (which would be like the difference between saying "giraffes are animals" and "'giraffe' is a noun") but rather just a case of ambiguity - "nothing" used in its normal sense or asa proper name. Still, I think it's a nice little philosophical example.